Both Lula Library and The Change made my Top Reads lists for 2023 and 2024, so when I found myself in a bit of a reading rut, I turned to Kirsten Miller again to pull me out and The Women of Wild Hill did not disappoint.
I loved about 95% of this book. It takes its time getting the present-day story rolling, as we dive deep into the Duncan family history but honestly, I didn’t mind one bit. The backstory is absolutely fascinating. There are witches, poisoners, Nazi-hunters, women burned at the stake, and so many ghosts. Each women has such a unique and flushed out story and I just loved it! Even though we meet Brigid and Phoebe in the present and they’re our main POCs, the history of their ancestors was stellar.
Brigid especially stood out for me. She’s complex, fierce, and flawed in all the best ways. Phoebe, was good too and created to the opposite of Brigid She’s smart, empathetic, and full of growth but like damn Phoebe, maybe actually talk to your sister. Their story is a whirlwind of death, reconciliation, sisterhood, romance, secrets, and a very a dose of feminist rage and magic.
This book is definitely Miller’s most overtly feminist yet like, yes, it’s very “fight the patriarchy,” and while I hate calling it “woke,” it’s unapologetically bold in its messaging (and I loved that). If that’s your vibe, you’re going to have a blast with this one.
Also, Harriet fans you’ll be happy. There’s a cameo that ties The Change into this universe, so I highly recommend reading that one first to avoid small spoilers and get the full experience.
Kirsten Miller is now firmly on my auto-buy list. Her writing is sharp, immersive, and electric with righteous fury and wit. I already miss this wild, witchy world. 4.5 stars rounded up to 5.
The Change Review
Lula Dean’s Library of Banned Books Review
AMAZON | GOODREADS | BOOKSHOP | ★★★★★
The Women of Wild Hill comes out October 7, 2025. Huge thank you to William Morrow for my advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion. If you liked this review please let me know either by commenting below or by visiting my instagram @speakingof.books.
